Consumer and Contract Today is committed to the integrity of the scholarly record. This page sets out the ethical standards expected of authors, reviewers and editors, and how the journal responds to concerns. The journal refers to the guidance and flowcharts of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). The journal is not a COPE member and makes no claim of membership. The publisher's full policy is at Publication Ethics and Malpractice.

Authors

  • Submit original work that is not published or under review elsewhere, and credit other people's ideas, words and data. See the Originality policy.
  • Report sources, data and legal authorities accurately: cite cases, statutes and regulations as they actually say, and do not rely on a source you have not read. Fabrication, falsification and selective presentation are misconduct.
  • List as authors only those who made a substantial contribution, approved the final version and accept responsibility for it. Honorary, gift and ghost authorship are not acceptable.
  • Disclose funding and any relationship with a business, trade association, consumer organisation, regulator or party to a case that could reasonably be seen to affect the work, including any role the author had in a dispute or policy discussed.
  • For research involving interviews, surveys, consumers, business actors or other people, state the ethical approval or exemption obtained and how informed consent and confidentiality were handled. Take particular care with personal data of consumers and with confidential commercial information.
  • Declare any use of generative AI tools, as set out in the Generative AI policy.
  • Tell the journal promptly about a significant error in a published article, so that a correction or retraction can follow.

Reviewers

Reviewers keep manuscripts confidential, assess them objectively and on time, declare conflicts of interest and decline when they cannot be impartial, and do not use unpublished material for their own benefit. A reviewer who suspects misconduct tells the editor and does not investigate alone. See the Peer Review policy.

Editors

  • Decide on academic merit alone, free of bias based on the authors' identity, nationality, gender, religion, politics or institution.
  • Keep manuscripts and reviews confidential.
  • Step aside from any manuscript where they have a conflict of interest, including their own work or that of colleagues and close collaborators, and ensure an independent editor handles it.
  • Do not use the journal to inflate citations to the journal or to any person's work.
  • Act on credible reports of misconduct, including for articles already published.

How concerns are handled

  1. Report. Anyone may raise a concern with the editorial office through the contact page. Anonymous reports are considered if they contain enough detail.
  2. Assess. The Editor-in-Chief, or the publisher if the Editor-in-Chief is involved, decides whether the concern is plausible and what evidence is needed.
  3. Investigate. Those concerned are told what is alleged and may answer in writing. The editor may consult reviewers, outside experts or the author's institution.
  4. Decide and act. The outcome can be a clarification, correction, expression of concern, retraction, a period of exclusion from submitting, or a report to the author's institution or funder. See the Corrections and Retractions policy.
  5. Record. The journal keeps a confidential record of the case and the reasons for the outcome.

A disagreement with an editorial decision is handled as an appeal under the complaints policy.

Readers may comment on published articles by writing to the editorial office through the contact page. Accepted comments and the authors' replies are published and linked to the article. See Post-publication discussion in the Corrections and Retractions policy.

Editorial independence

Editorial decisions are not influenced by the publisher, by funders or by the journal's collaboration with the Center of Commercial and Corporate Law (C3L), Universitas Muhammadiyah Magelang. The journal charges authors no fee.